An angler on a boat holding up a large Lake Ontario brown trout under a clear blue sky

Resort & Marina · Fair Haven, NY

Fishing at
Turtle Cove

Two fisheries, one home port. Cast Little Sodus Bay for pike, walleye, perch, and bass, or run out to Lake Ontario for trophy salmon and trout — then dock right back at the resort.

Home port

Two fisheries, one dock.

Turtle Cove sits where the protected bay meets the open lake — so you choose your water by the day.

Stay on the water, walk to your boat, and fish two of New York’s best fisheries without ever loading the trailer.

An angler on the Turtle Cove dock holding up a large Lake Ontario salmon
Back at the dock with a Lake Ontario salmon.

What’s biting

Protected water or open lake.

Pick the bay for an easy, relaxed day, or run past the harbor mouth for the big cold-water fish.

An angler on the lawn at Turtle Cove holding a large walleye A cooler lid covered in yellow perch caught on Little Sodus Bay
01 Protected water

Little Sodus Bay

750Acres
35 ftMax depth

A sheltered inlet on Lake Ontario’s southern shore, midway between Syracuse and Rochester — the easy, relaxed day on the water.

In the bay
  • Northern Pike
  • Walleye
  • Yellow Perch
  • Smallmouth Bass
  • Largemouth Bass
  • Pumpkinseed
  • Bluegill
  • Rock Bass
  • Crappie
  • White Perch
  • Carp
  • Bullheads
  • Channel Catfish
Two anglers on the Turtle Cove dock each holding a king salmon Two anglers on a boat on Lake Ontario, each holding up a fresh-caught salmon
02 Open water

Lake Ontario

6Trophy species

Run out past the harbor mouth onto one of the best cold-water fisheries in the country — salmon and trout that draw anglers from everywhere.

On the lake
  • Brown Trout
  • Rainbow Trout
  • Lake Trout
  • Coho Salmon
  • Chinook Salmon
  • Atlantic Salmon
Ice fishing shanties out on frozen Little Sodus Bay under a gray winter sky

Through the ice

The bay doesn’t close for winter.

When Little Sodus Bay freezes over, the shanties come out. The bay’s ice fishing is known for northern pike and yellow perch — a whole different season on the same water.

Ice conditions change fast. Check local reports before heading out.

Current Fishing Report
Nautical chart of Little Sodus Bay, New York, with depth soundings from the harbor mouth south to Fair Haven
Little Sodus Bay, charted — harbor mouth at the top, Fair Haven along the east shore.

Know the water

Little Sodus Bay, charted.

A long, sheltered bay that opens north onto Lake Ontario through a single channel. Fair Haven sits on the east shore — bay fishing out the back door, open lake minutes away.

Surface area
750 acres
Max depth
35 ft
Opens onto
Lake Ontario
Ice season favorites
Pike & perch

Bay facts: NYS DEC

Local charters

Want a guide who knows the grounds?

Two local captains we recommend, plus the county report to check before you load the cooler.

Your home port

Make Turtle Cove your home port.

Stay on the water, walk to your boat, and fish two of New York’s best fisheries from one dock.

Book Your Stay Call 315-947-6677

356 King St., Fair Haven, NY